by SJHooper » Thu Mar 10, 2016 5:50 pm
Very fair analysis, great job! Yes the season is finally over. Here's my recap of what went right and what went wrong and our outlook.
What went right:
-Have to admit, I laughed seeing Ellison for much of the season because he looked like a HS player. Missing layups routinely, coughing the ball up almost every possession, failing on 3 on 1 fast breaks, etc. But he did much better at the end of the season and looked like he can be at worst a solid guy off the bench.
-Sima is a legitimate big who can defend, block, AND score. It was awesome having Obekpa (pre-marijuana bust) and his block parties, but he was awful offensively. Sima is already lightyears better than him offensively and just as good defensively. And he's a freshman. If he stays 4 years he will be our Stainbrook.
-Mussini...now many fans may say how overrated he was, since he didn't have a great year. But anyone who knows hoops knows that Mussini is NOT a PG and was playing totally out of position all year. He is a catch and shoot guy, and if there's one thing he showed us, it's that he only needs a bit of room to get it off and can shoot from anywhere on the court. He will be a very good 4 year player as a catch and shoot guy.
-Coaching staff. There have been nothing but rave reviews from our new recruiting studs Matt A and Slice. They have already shown the ability to keep top local talent home and reel in 4 star kids even in awful rebuilding years. They are generating lots of buzz locally. You can tell they are also finding kids with real skill (Sima, Mussini, Yakwe) instead of Lavin's administration recruiting general athletes who were solid at everything but great at nothing. Greg St. Jean is also a very young hungry kid who is really enjoying his role. Yes it's true that Mullin defers to him in many huddles or timeouts, but remember he never coached before and even if St. Jean takes charge more in the huddle, who cares? College hoops is more about recruiting than coaching IMO. Look at any top 25 team and 90% of them will be chock full of 4 and 5 star kids. As long as you recruit well, balance classes, motivate the kids, and know how to develop them over 4 years, you will succeed in college.
What went wrong:
-Carnesecca Arena is an abomination. The place literally keeps fans away it's so hot and uncomfortable. No seatbacks on most of the seats, no concessions, no luxury, no comfort, and our scoreboard is outdated. The student section is a joke. It has room for about 20 people on each end and it's 15 feet above the court. It needs to either be renovated in a major way, or demolished and rebuilt completely. Yes we play at MSG, but CA should still be a nice arena. We are in the media capital of the world in arguably the biggest basketball city on earth and we are the only NYC team in major hoops. I don't get how all these other schools are getting new stadiums on the reg and we must continue to put up with CA which looks like it hasn't been changed since 1998 and has the luxuries of a little league ballpark.
-Turnovers...missed layups...just a complete mess. The Cuse game was one of the very few games this team actually clicked on all cylinders. Much of this had to do with inexperience and bad players.
-Do we ever win tournament games? Big East or NCAA? I mean it seriously feels like we never do. Even early season tournaments. SJ has a terrible reputation for falling flat on our faces in tournaments. I really don't get it. This goes across coaches and across different teams.
-Refs were absolutely horrendous pretty consistently. Even Raf said "jeez let them play this has been the worst officiating ever". Blowing a whistle every minute and calling 50 fouls is just slaughtering the fan experience at games.
-Everything else that could go wrong essentially did. We also have the hex of being known for severely underperforming. We almost never overperform. The only program that has underperformed worse than us in recent years is G'Town.
Outlook:
-SJ figures to be around a 15 win team next year. The talent will be on an entirely different level, but the consistency will not be there. Inexperience almost always catches up with you unless you are Kentucky, Duke, or Kansas. McDonald's AA's might make instant impacts, but top 50 kids need a few years before getting comfortable and consistent. Our recruiting has been very good and there is a lot of hype around us. We had pretty good turnout for most games despite being arguably the worst major conference team this year in the country. That shows hope. Forget Elite 8's and Final Four's and top 10 rankings. If we can make the NCAA's every other year and appear in the top 25 at some point on and off most years, you will see tons of fans awaken from their slumber. If this team was top 10 and made Sweet 16's and Elite 8's, St. John's games would look like Knicks games. That means sold out. I'm hopeful, but I'm also a realist. Usually when things seem too good to be true at SJ (Lavin, Mullin, etc.) they usually are. Let's see what Mullin can do.